As previewed by MassTortDefense, the Food and Drug Administration held a public hearing on October 2, 2008, to obtain input regarding over-the-counter (OTC) cough and cold drugs marketed for pediatric use. Many of these nonprescription cough and cold drug products are marketed under the OTC Drug Review, which published a monograph describing the conditions under which certain OTC ingredients are considered to be generally recognized as safe and effective. These products contain ingredients that have been classified by the FDA as generally recognized as safe and effective since the 1970’s Recently, some potential safety and efficacy concerns have been raised regarding the pediatric dosing and use of certain active ingredients in OTC cough and cold drug products.
FDA is developing a proposed rule to revise the pediatric labeling guidance contained in the Final Monograph for Cough, Cold, Allergy, Bronchodilator, and Antiasthmatic Drug Products for Over-the-Counter Human Use. Each year, U.S. consumers buy about 95 million packages of oral pediatric cough and cold medicines.
Some doctors at the hearing urged regulators to seek removal of children’s cough and cold medicines from store shelves until the products are found safe and effective. For example, Dr. Michael Shannon, professor at Harvard Medical School, testified that it is time for these products to be re-evaluated regarding their risk-benefit ratio. The American Academy of Pediatrics doesn’t recommend any use of OTC cold and cough medicines in children. In January, the FDA recommended against their use in children up to 2 years old. Treatment alternatives include providing fluids, nose drops, humid air and appropriate pain relievers.
The Consumer Healthcare Products Association pointed out that most reported side effects are caused by accidental overdose and misuse, which might suggest that changed packaging and improved education, rather than other measures, might be appropriate. The Association has begun a comprehensive, national education program that focuses on the root causes of adverse events and speaks directly to parents, day care providers, healthcare providers, and other caregivers. CHPA is partnering with a number of organizations in these efforts, including the American Pharmacists Association and the American Association of Family Physicians. These education campaigns underscore the importance of following the directions on the label, using the correct dose, storing medicines safely and consulting with a doctor if there are any questions.
Arguably, if pediatric cough and cold products are no longer available over the counter, parents may turn to other alternatives that may result in even more dangerous consequences for children. The industry is undertaking a comprehensive and scientifically rigorous efficacy and safety program for children age 2 to 12 in order to advance the science and ensure the highest level of scientific rigor. This program includes pharmacokinetic studies to confirm the dosing for the eight most commonly used OTC oral cough and cold ingredients. Once these dosing studies are finalized, they will begin other studies to revalidate the effectiveness of these medicines.
In reaction to the public hearing, FDA did not call for an immediate ban on over-the-counter cough and cold medicines for young children. John Jenkins, director of the FDA’s Office of New Drugs, said the agency will propose changing its rules which could further restrict use of the products in children.
In response to the issues, following the hearing, makers of OTC cold and cough drugs announced they would start adding warnings against use in children younger than 4 years. That is, the leading manufacturers of these medicines are voluntarily transitioning the labeling on oral OTC pediatric cough and cold medicines to state “do not use” in children under four years of age. (The risk of overdose is greatest in 2- and 3-year-olds, according to the Consumer Healthcare Products Association.) Pediatric antihistamines will also carry new labels telling parents not to use the medicines to sedate children of any age. The move comes out of an abundance of caution in an effort to promote the safe and effective use of these medicines. FDA was quoted as being in support of these voluntary actions by CHPA, in part because the rulemaking process can take significant time.